| Platinum | Dunkin' |
| Platinum | Hot Table Panini |
| Gold | Auntie Cathie's Kitchen |
| Silver | Koffee Kup Bakery |
| Bronze | Pane Dolcetti |
| Top Pick | Agawam's Java Stop |
| Top Pick | Monsoon Roastery & Espresso Bar |
| Top Pick | Nosh |
| Top Pick | The Better Bean |
| Top Pick | The Student Prince Cafe & The Fort |
